TEACHING GUIDE
Reply Across
Give your advice. Then find out what history did.
Letters arrive from Canada in 1992 and India in 1956. Give advice on sharing power, make a prediction and answer an objection. Only then open the historical record and decide what your original advice can still defend.

Choose how to play
For Class requires Full. Complete the required decisions, evidence checks and explanations, then assemble the report. Printing and assignment-report downloads unlock when that work is current. Progress backups remain available throughout.
For Fun: explore at your own pace. Where Core and Full length choices are offered, they are available in For Fun. Exploration reports are personal records.
Use your own reasoning and acknowledge assistance under your course rules. Enter your own answers directly. Paste and text drop are disabled in For Class response fields. Completion checks do not grade the quality of the written reasoning.
What you will do
- Advise Canada and India before opening the later historical record.
- Answer the authored objections while keeping the original advice visible.
- Complete the dated follow-up, category audit, transfer, assembled reply and debrief. Spain is an optional postscript.
Learning goals
- Compare institutional responses to national and linguistic diversity.
- Identify minorities within proposed territorial units.
- Distinguish a defensible prediction from hindsight.
Before you begin
Best after a basic introduction to nationalism.
Plan 60–80 min for the activity and make room for discussion. Longer activities can be paused between files or chapters. Keep Full as the Class route across those sessions.
Bring it back to the room
- Which part of your advice survives the later record?
- What travels between Canada and India, and what does not?
What to assess
Assess dated evidence, explicit predictions, objections and the scope of comparative claims.
Ask what the learner chose, which observation supports the explanation, what followed and what would lead them to reconsider. A retained judgment can be as defensible as a changed one. Hints should support a reasoning move while leaving the interpretation to the learner.
Save, return and submit
If sealing a reply reveals a missing input, the notice identifies and focuses the expectation, reason, recommendation, evidence insert or safeguard control and offers a return link. The unfamiliar-transfer instructions remain visible beside the writing field while drafting. These controls preserve the existing evidence and historical-reveal gates.
Check the activity’s save status. Download a JSON progress backup before changing websites, browsers or devices, and use its restore control to resume. Device saves do not synchronize between the two websites.
For Class, complete all required Full work and the final report action. Then use the report’s Print / Save as PDF or other readable export control and follow your instructor’s submission instructions. Downloading does not submit your work. A JSON backup restores progress; it is not the assignment report.
Sources and scope
Canadian materials define justiciability as whether the proposed new self-government clause could be enforced in court; its five-year delay is separate from existing rights. Jurisdiction and remedy receive local plain-language glosses. CA-E04 remains contemporary 1992 commentary with an unverified original distribution day. Use it as context, and do not claim the correspondents had read it before the 1 October freeze. No distribution date has been inferred.
Historical cases are selected for comparison, not equivalent experiments. The optional Spain postscript adds a further comparison.
Use the source notes and dated records supplied in the activity when supporting a claim. Keep the difference between a fictional model and historical evidence clear.
Optional debrief
After the first India response, compare the same objection under Article 3 and a hypothetical state veto. Ask what Parliament is allowed to consider under each rule.