Who Gets
to Decide?
Who can vote, and who can make the decision?
Edit a guide to political power in Israel and the Palestinian territories. Compare who can vote and who can make or challenge decisions, then test Sammy Smooha’s and Oren Yiftachel’s approaches on the same evidence.

Use the same test across dates and places.
Part 1. Start with a family’s effort to get a plot in Katzir. Compare a court order, a Knesset vote and a land council roster. Choose a test for democracy and apply it to citizens inside the Green Line in spring 2000.
Part 2. Add West Bank cases and examine the November 2026 evidence on elections, the Nation-State Law, study and medical work, local welfare and territorial control. Trace who could vote and who decided in each case, including cases from East Jerusalem and Gaza.
The simulation teaches Smooha’s ethnic democracy and Yiftachel’s ethnocracy before asking you to use both. Write the first version of your guide, then respond to a reader who brings a documented case that puts your claim under pressure. You can keep, qualify, change or leave your judgment open.
Teach with this case.
For Class records seven short written responses. Have students pause after the first judgment, about 35 minutes in. They can back up progress as JSON and submit their completed PDF report through your course. For Fun covers the same evidence with optional writing.