States and markets / In-class activity
Who Picks Up the Tab?
If a deal is bad, can you just walk away?
I start with a ticket that looks affordable until the fee appears. Then I ask what other choice the buyer actually has. Students take that question into five real cases, make a prediction, and use the evidence to decide what they would do about it.
50 minutes · In pairs · About 30 students

Classroom materials
Open the guide first. It takes you from seating and printing through the five brief hearings, a five-minute debrief, and the individual exit question. The case sheets have the background and data students need.
Print for 30
Print pages 1–10 of the student packet three times, double-sided, flipping on the long edge. Print 15 single-sided copies of page 11 and cut them in half. Give each pair one case sheet and each student one slip.
Bring pens and a timer. The guide includes a board-only option and adjustments for different class sizes. Students can start without advance reading.
- Instructor guide (PDF)
Setup, 50-minute clock, read-aloud prompts, debrief, and evidence key.
- PowerPoint slides (PPTX)
Ten poster slides with speaker notes.
- Slide deck (PDF)
The ten posters for projection or sharing.
- Student case packet (PDF)
Five two-sided cases with data tables and an individual slip on page 11.
- Individual slips and hearing tally (PDF)
Two slips per page on page 1. The optional instructor tally is on page 2.
What you’ll do in class
With your partner, take one role each, make a choice, and predict what will happen when a rule changes. Wait for the signal to turn your sheet over. Read the study result, try the move again, and give a reason for your final vote. Listen for what changed in two other cases. You’ll end with a short answer of your own.
You can speak, point, or write during the scene. Bring your reasoning to the hearing and say who might still pay or lose out.