POLITICS. TEACHING. OTHER QUESTIONABLE INTERESTS.
Back to Class Work

States and markets / In-class activity

Who Picks Up the Tab?

If a deal is bad, can you just walk away?

I start with a ticket that looks affordable until the fee appears. Then I ask what other choice the buyer actually has. Students take that question into five real cases, make a prediction, and use the evidence to decide what they would do about it.

50 minutes · In pairs · About 30 students

Screenprinted concert tickets held outside a lit music venue at dusk.
Created by Yoav Duman

Classroom materials

Open the guide first. It takes you from seating and printing through the five brief hearings, a five-minute debrief, and the individual exit question. The case sheets have the background and data students need.

Print for 30

Print pages 1–10 of the student packet three times, double-sided, flipping on the long edge. Print 15 single-sided copies of page 11 and cut them in half. Give each pair one case sheet and each student one slip.

Bring pens and a timer. The guide includes a board-only option and adjustments for different class sizes. Students can start without advance reading.

What you’ll do in class

With your partner, take one role each, make a choice, and predict what will happen when a rule changes. Wait for the signal to turn your sheet over. Read the study result, try the move again, and give a reason for your final vote. Listen for what changed in two other cases. You’ll end with a short answer of your own.

You can speak, point, or write during the scene. Bring your reasoning to the hearing and say who might still pay or lose out.